Dental News - Don’t tax health benefits, dental groups say

Fred Michmershuizen, DTA

Wed. 13 January 2010

save

NEW YORK, NY, USA: As lawmakers in Washington hash out the details of proposed reform to the nation’s health care system, a number of dental associations — including the American Dental Association (ADA), the Academy of General Dentistry (AGD) and others — are crying foul over a key sticking point: a proposed tax on employer-sponsored health coverage.

The provision, as written, is “the opposite of health care reform,” said ADA President Ron Tankersley, DDS. “It would compel many employers to drop critical dental and other coverage to avoid the tax. It dismantles exactly the type of preventive, primary care that everyone agrees this country needs more of.”

Democrats from the House and Senate have been in discussions to resolve numerous differences in the health care reform bills passed by the two chambers to expand coverage to millions of Americans who lack any coverage and to rein in the costs of health care.

Under the Senate’s version of the bill, the federal government would impose a 40 percent tax on the value of employer-sponsored health coverage that exceeds US$8,500 a year for individuals and US$23,000 for families. The Senate bill would make certain allowances for plans covering retirees 55 and older and workers in high-risk occupations. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that the tax would raise US$149 billion over 10 years.

The House version of the bill would not tax health benefits.

President Barack Obama, who has indicated that he is in favor of the tax, is pushing for Congress to reconcile the bills so he can sign the legislation into law before his State of the Union address in February. But the proposed tax has unleashed a fury of opposition. Many argue that to avoid the tax, many employers would simply drop supplemental dental and vision coverage for their employees. In addition to the ADA and AGD, a number of other dental associations are also opposed to the tax. They include the American College of Prosthodontists, the American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry, the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons, the American Association of Orthodontists and the Hispanic Dental Association.

All of these associations sent a joint letter to Congress asking leaders of the House and Senate to eliminate or substantially modify the excise tax on health benefits, including flexible spending accounts (FSAs), to ensure the final health care reform legislation does not adversely impact key and important goals of health reform, like primary and prevention-oriented care.

“Many employer-sponsored plans exceed or will exceed the PPACA excise tax threshold simply because the plans include many older workers or retirees with higher cost health care needs, or are concentrated in locations with high health costs,” the letter states. “For example, the standard option BCBS Federal Employees Health Benefit plan, a basic plan that covers 3.8 million Americans today, will exceed the PPACA excise threshold in the first year of the tax (2013) for single coverage and in the third year of the tax (2016) for family coverage.”

The letter continues, “As a result, the excise tax could lead many employers to reduce benefits by eliminating limited service supplemental benefits and FSAs that fund much-needed and prevention-oriented dental and vision care in order to avoid the tax. Cuts in these crucial benefits will lead to a decline in access to necessary care. Patients rely on the preventive services covered by the dental, vision and limited service supplemental plans to prevent infections, slow the progress of chronic disease and facilitate early treatment of preventable conditions.”

The coalition is proposing alternatives to the tax, including the following:

- Excluding FSAs, as well as managed and limited service dental, vision and stand-alone plans, from the calculation of health plan costs.
- Raising the threshold and indexing the threshold to medical inflation.
- Replacing the single and family coverage thresholds with a per-covered-person threshold, a fairer approach to plan cost allocation.

Many House Democrats are opposed to the health care benefits tax, and at least 190 representatives signed a letter opposing such a tax.

“The view of many progressives is that the tax is unacceptable,” Rep. Jerrold Nadler, Democrat of New York, told The New York Times. “It would affect a lot of middle-income people.”

“The health care reform debate has never centered on dental, vision and other supplemental benefits,” said James A. Klein, president of the American Benefits Council. “Those valuable benefits have only been included in the calculation of the excise tax to raise revenue. Several modifications are needed to improve the excise tax provision, including not applying the tax to these important supplemental benefits.”

“For millions of patients and consumers, most of whom are middle and low income working Americans, the excise tax is unfair and punitive, leading to reduced health care services,” said Louise Novotny, research director at Communications Workers of America.

To post a reply please login or register

Expert group questions benefits of fluoridation

LEIPZIG, Germany: Experts at the 28th Conference of the International Society for Fluoride Research in Toronto, Canada, have raised new concerns about the ...

Research shows Americans with dental benefits have better overall health

DALLAS, TX/NEW YORK CITY, NY, USA: Individuals with dental benefits are more likely to go to the dentist, take their children to the dentist, ...

Experts say a dental public health infrastructure is needed in California

SACREMENTO, Calif., USA: The January issue of the Journal of the California Dental Association continues to examine issues relating to the dental workforce ...

Don’t let braces hinder hygiene

If you’re an orthodontist who would like to help your patients maintain a better level of hygiene care, you’ll want to learn more about Ortho ...

Fortune 500 insurer to offer dental benefits

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn., USA: The American-Anglo Unum Group is adding dental insurance to its portfolio of financial protection benefits, Dental Tribune ONLINE ...

Academy of Nutrition and dietetics touts the health benefits of fluoride

CHICAGO, Ill., USA: Fluoride provides health benefits throughout a person’s life, especially for bones and teeth, according to the Academy of ...

Teeth and gums may benefit from Aloe Vera

CHICAGO, IL, USA: The aloe vera plant has a long history of healing power. Its ability to heal burns and cuts and soothe pain has been documented as far ...

Viscardi Center’s ‘Take a Dental Health Day’ helps those with disabilities

ALBERTSON, N.Y., USA: The Viscardi Center’s Project Accessible Oral Health Initiative hosted its first “Take a Dental Health Day — Screening and ...

Healthy gums may lead to healthy lungs

CHICAGO: Maintaining periodontal health may contribute to a healthy respiratory system, according to research published in the Journal of Periodontology. A ...