As Rushworth Kidder (2006) suggested, moral courage bridges talking ethically and performing ethically. Although Kidder’s book is meant for everyone, it is a must for physicians and dentists. Performing ethically is not always easy and is therefore important to be stressed during formal educational programs. Dental students must recognize that moral courage is frequently needed to address ethical issues in order to take action for doing the right thing when questionable issues arise with patients that place the clinician in an uncomfortable position.
Health-care professionals often face complex ethical dilemmas in the workplace; some clinicians tackle ethical issues directly while others turn away. Regardless of whether a doctor is involved with private clinical practice, education, research or administration, they are not immune to facing moral dilemmas or experiencing unethical behavior. Moral courage takes into account the principles of ethics and the courage to act accordingly. Courage is not the absence of fear … it is doing what’s right even in the presence of fear.
Educators and scholars have disputed the diverse meaning of moral courage over the centuries. Ancient Greek philosophers Plato and Aristotle repeatedly used this term in reference to character on the battlefield, discussing courage as a trait set aside for situations where individuals feared death. Aristotle specifically discussed moral courage in the context of being able to wage war while being mindful of the possibility of injury or death. To Aristotle, bravery was a virtue that enabled Greek soldiers to respond appropriately to the fear of the battle.
How a doctor responds to ethical dilemmas depends on his or her (a) previous experiences with unethical behavior, (b) individual personality traits, (c) moral values, and (d) knowledge of social justice principles, for which moral courage is needed to confront unethical behaviors. As a result of cost control procedures, inadequate staff levels, shortage of clinicians in some areas delivering patient care, merging of health-care organizations and ineffective leadership, there is an increase of ethical dilemmas in the health-care milieu today and it directly affects all doctors.
The AAO’s Principles of Ethics and Professional Code of Conduct, Section VI, states, “Members may exercise discretion in selecting a patient into their practice, provided they shall not refuse to accept the patient because of the patient’s race, creed, color, sex, national origin, disability, HIV seropositive status or other legally recognized protected class.”
Although dental schools and hospital clinics often accept fee reimbursement from federal funding, most private practitioners do not. It is considered discriminatory for a dental school or hospital faculty to reject a patient based on a disability, even though a “contract” between the clinic and the patient at a screening evaluation might not yet have been established.
It would also be unwise to refuse a patient from your private practice if the reason is based on discrimination, including any of the reasons listed in the AAO’s Principles of Ethics and Professional Code of Conduct.
Even though there is no universally accepted Hippocratic oath for dentists, it should be stressed to our dental students that they must adhere to affirmations such as:
- I may not always do what’s right, but I will always try to do what’s right.
- It is sometimes hard to do the right thing and sometimes hard to know what the right thing is, but once you know what that is, do it!
A temperamental tolerance of courage over timidity is needed when facing risk management issues. The tenets of decision-making are related to ethics and social justice principles, which directly begs the clinician’s ability to serve the (a) individual, and (b) community (educational services, outreach programs, welfare agencies, public service, etc.), are risk management issues (Walzer, 1983). Such concerns are becoming increasingly more critical for the profession as well as society.
According to Wren (1995), “Since the function of leadership is to produce change, setting the direction of that change is fundamental to leadership.” Setting direction and planning are two separated activities — activities that coincide with teaching and which directly relate to teaching our dental students how to ethically and morally cope with adversity and risk.
Note: This article was published in Ortho Tribune U.S. Edition, Vol. 8, No. 1, Spring 2013 issue. A complete list of references is available upon request from the publisher.
NEWPORT BEACH, Calif., USA: New research conducted on behalf of the Oral Cancer Foundation has found that many Americans are unaware of the fact that the ...
To continue the discussion regarding what our residents are missing in his or her orthodontic training, nothing is a better teacher than personal ...
PHILADELPHIA, Pa., USA: On Saturday, June 23, the Academy of General Dentistry (AGD) and the AGD Foundation will partner with the University of Pennsylvania...
The rapid emergence of digital technology for capturing intraoral X-ray images is a global trend and is driving growth in the overall dental imaging market....
There are compelling advantages to both private practice and academics. For each graduating resident, career decisions come down to determining which ...
CHARLOTTE, N.C., USA: The America’s ToothFairy Smile Drive will be held this February. Students united with America’s ToothFairy national youth ...
Are orthodontists responsible for examining the occlusion, teeth and gingiva? Yes, for sure, but we also have a responsibility to use our training and ...
CHICAGO, Ill., USA: During the recent Chicago Midwinter Meeting, DEXIS, i-CAT and Henry Schein Dental hosted “The Art of Imaging” at the Chicago...
BUFFALO, N.Y., US: As the field of medicine continues to evolve, the American Dental Association (ADA) has recognised the importance of integrating ...
When was the last time you built something? I mean really built something, anything from scratch? Do you think you can do it? Do you have the tools to do ...
Live webinar
Thu. 18 July 2024
8:00 PM EST (New York)
Live webinar
Fri. 26 July 2024
11:00 AM EST (New York)
Live webinar
Tue. 6 August 2024
6:00 PM EST (New York)
Live webinar
Tue. 13 August 2024
7:00 PM EST (New York)
Live webinar
Wed. 14 August 2024
12:30 PM EST (New York)
Live webinar
Wed. 21 August 2024
9:00 AM EST (New York)
Dr. Jim Lai DMD, MSc(Perio), EdD, FRCD(C)
Live webinar
Thu. 22 August 2024
4:00 PM EST (New York)
To post a reply please login or register